User talk:Scottwrites/Twing

From WikiProjectMed
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Notability

Here are my thoughts concerning this article. As of now, I think it would be borderline in terms of an AfD. I would probably give it a weak delete because notability hasn't truly been established. To establish notability, the best thing which you can provide are reputable, third party sources discussing Twing.com. Currently, this article only lists one such source: the ABC interview. This alone may be enough to pass the WP:N threshhold. I am not sure though. The other links in the "External links" section are all rather weak in terms of "reputable", consisting mainly of personal or special interest blogs. As for the two sources cited in the actual article, neither one of them are specifically about Twing.com.

What would be best if you truly want this article to pass the Notability threshhold would be to find some reputable third-party sources (such as magazine and newspaper reviews) specifically discussing the subject of the article and then incorporate and cite the information from these third-party sources directly into the article. (You may even want to try and do this with information gleaned from the ABC source.)

If you are able to find such sources, please feel free to get in touch with me and I can help you incorporate them into this article properly.

I hope this helps you on your way! :-) -- Levine2112 discuss 17:38, 2 September 2008 (UTC)[reply]

Retrieved from "https://mdwiki.org/wiki/User_talk:Scottwrites/Twing"