User talk:Littlemunk

From WikiProjectMed
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Hello. I believe your recent edits to James Frey are contrary to Wikipedia policy. The article was the subject of many edits when the memoir fabrication controversy arose. Based on the numerous edits and the talk page discussion, a consensus was arrived at and I think the article's discussion of the controversy essential stabilized in December 2006. It appears that the section was maintained with minor changes until July 2008, at which point you made massive deletions. I think these deletions are contrary to Wikipedia policies to preserve information, to arrive at consensus, and to maintain a neutral point of view. Articles should not be scrubbed of notable, factual, well-sourced information that happens to reflect poorly on the article's subject. Massive deletions should not occur without consensus and discussions on the article's Talk page. You have not justified your changes on the Talk pages. You haven't provided a discussion or edit summaries regarding your reversion of massive deletions of my recent restoration of the deleted information. --JamesAM (talk) 19:37, 18 September 2008 (UTC)[reply]