User:Bdevalk/sandbox

From WikiProjectMed
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Structural Evil

Structural evil or systemic evil is evil which arises from structures within human society, rather than from individual wickedness or religious conceptions such as original sin. One example of Structural evil within a society would be slavery.

Structural evil arises within human societies because of the way humans act. Multiple individuals have commented and theorized on the subject of structural evil. Among these early thinkers are Rousseau and Robespierre. However, more modern thinkers on this subject are Thomas Nagel, Claudia Card, Cynthia D. Moe-Lobeda, and John Langan.

Early Thinkers

Jean-Jacques Rousseau

Rousseau proposed that the structures of human society were the main source of evil in his works such as the Discourse on Inequality (Discours sur l'origine et les fondements de l'inégalité parmi les hommes).[2] He believed that humans are good by nature, but are rendered corrupt by society.[1] Rousseau's reasoning is as follows: if society is supposedly composed of entirely naturally good human beings, then how can evil come about? It must come about because of the structures that are present in human society.[1] These ideas were influential upon French revolutionaries such as Robespierre.[2]

Modern Thinkers

Thomas Nagel

Thomas Nagel is a modern philosopher who has argued that the great evils of the 20th century, such as genocide, required extensive structural support from the societies in which they occurred.[3] He believes that while a few individuals have the capacity to hurt other individuals, the capacity needed to deliver the amount of destructiveness found in the great evils of the 20th century requires extensive organizational structure.[2] Individuals, such as Adolf Hitler, Josef Stalin, and Pol Pot, he noted may have been able to influence a whole society; however, they achieved this through manipulation of a wider social structure.[2]

Claudia Card

Claudia Card is another modern theorist who has defined structural evil as being intolerable harm which results from the normal operation of social structures.[4] Her list of such institutions is controversial as it includes marriage and motherhood.[5]

John Langan

John Langan, an American author, criticized and summarized Pope John Paul II ideas of how structural evil arises.[3] Langan states, "Institutions, structures, and societies are not the subject of moral acts, ... 'social sins are the result of the accumulation and concentration of many personal sins.'" After stating this, he points out a few criticisms in Pope John Paul II's theory.[3]

Cynthia D. Moe- Lobeda

In 2013, Cynthia D. Moe-Lobeda, a professor of Theological and Social Ethics at Pacific Lutheran Theological Seminary, proposed that structural evil is seen in everyday life and disguised through good, inevitability, divine mandate, and social necessity.[6] Moe-Lobeda is the author of a novel published in 2013 titled: Resisting Structural Evil : Love as Ecological and Economic Vocation.

Resisting Structural Evil: Love as Ecological and Economic Vocation (Cynthia D. Moe-Lobeda, 2013)

Cynthia D. Moe-Lobeda wrote that Structural Evil consists of "chains that bind us into systemic exploitation of others and of the Earth," and that they are intricate and cleverly hidden. These "chains" come from the outside forces that include: power arrangements, ideologies, values, practices, and policies.[4] According to Moe-Lobeda, structural evil is not metaphysical. Although, it may go beyond the physical power of individuals to counter, but it is composed of power arrangements and other forces that are humanly constructed.[4]

Structural Evil in Western Society

According to Andrew Basden, a professor of Human Factors and Philosophy in Information Systems at Salford Business School at the University of Salford: Manchester, structural evil builds up and prevails because individuals contribute to its creation, accept it without protest to it and done so over a long period of time.[5] He also puts for that there is not just one kind of structural evil, but rather that there are many.

When viewing Western society, structural evil can be found in the following aspects of reality: [5]

  • Biotic
  • Sensitive
  • Analytical
  • Formative
  • Lingual
  • Social
  • Economic
  • Aesthetic
  • Juridical
  • Ethical
  • Pistic

See Also

Collective Guilt

Don't be evil

Notes

Further Reading

I would like to work on the structural evil article. Sources as well as information on the wiki page are limited at the moment.

There is not much listed on the wiki page, so this wiki article would benefit from the following:

  • A strong closing paragraph
  • Elaboration on Ideas as well as concepts (from specific individuals mentioned)
  • Additional Sources/More Evidence/More Sources
  • Contemporary Information (within the last 200 years)
  • Elaborate specifically on Rousseau's ideas of structural evil
    • Where did it come from? (Details about the source)
    • Origin of idea?
    • What is the significance of Rousseau's thinking on Robespierre -- elaborate on this. Since Robespierre is mentioned just once in the article, what was the significance of mentioning this individual?
  • Elaborate on Nagle and Card
    • Origin of idea?
    • Details! In addition to the things listed above, I would like to include examples of how the concept of "structural evil" can be seen throughout the world.

Working Bibliography/Additional Sources for Further Information

Balasuriya, Tissa. 2001. "World apartheid: our greatest structural evil." In Spiritual questions for the twenty-first century: essays in honor of Joan D. Chittister, 126-133. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Bks, 2001. ATLA Religion Database with ATLASerials, EBSCOhost (accessed October 20, 2016).

Lam, Wing Kwan Anselm, and Christopher J. 2009. The Natural Goodness of Man in Rousseau's Confessions--A Reply to Augustine's Confessions.Boston College. http://hdl.handle.net/2345/734.

Metzger, Paul Louis. 2004. "The sorcerer's apprentice and the Savior of the world: space, time, and structural evil." Cultural Encounters 1, no. 1: 85-93. ATLA Religion Database with ATLASerials, EBSCOhost (accessed October 20, 2016).

Moe-Lobeda, Cynthia D. 2013. Resisting Structural Evil : Love As Ecological and Economic Vocation. Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press.

Runzo, Joseph. 1992. Ethics, Religion, and the Good Society : New Directions in a Pluralistic World.Louisville, Ky.: Westminster/John Knox Press.

  1. ^ a b Bertram, Christopher (2012-01-01). Zalta, Edward N. (ed.). The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2012 ed.). Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University.
  2. ^ a b Goldburg, Peta; Blundell, Patricia; Jordan, Trevor (2011-04-01). Exploring Religion and Ethics: Religion and Ethics for Senior Secondary Students. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9780521187169.
  3. ^ a b Runzo, Joseph (1992). Ethics, Religion, and the Good Society: New Directions in a Pluralistic World. Louisville, Kentucky: Westminster/John Knox Press. p. 148. ISBN 0664252850.
  4. ^ a b Moe-Lobeda, Cynthia (2013). Resisting structural evil : love as ecological and economic vocation. Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press. ISBN 9781451462678.
  5. ^ a b "Evil In The Structure of Society". www.basden.demon.co.uk. Retrieved 2016-11-11.
Retrieved from "https://mdwiki.org/wiki/User:Bdevalk/sandbox"