Draft:National Football League Draft busts
Draft article not currently submitted for review.
This is a draft Articles for creation (AfC) submission. It is not currently pending review. While there are no deadlines, abandoned drafts may be deleted after six months. To edit the draft click on the "Edit" tab at the top of the window. To be accepted, a draft should:
It is strongly discouraged to write about yourself, your business or employer. If you do so, you must declare it. Where to get help
How to improve a draft
You can also browse Wikipedia:Featured articles and Wikipedia:Good articles to find examples of Wikipedia's best writing on topics similar to your proposed article. Improving your odds of a speedy review To improve your odds of a faster review, tag your draft with relevant WikiProject tags using the button below. This will let reviewers know a new draft has been submitted in their area of interest. For instance, if you wrote about a female astronomer, you would want to add the Biography, Astronomy, and Women scientists tags. Editor resources
Last edited by Citation bot (talk | contribs) 4 months ago. (Update) |
* | First overall pick | |||||
† | Second overall pick | |||||
+ | Picked in the first round | |||||
‡ | Heisman Trophy winner | In sports lore, there exists a superstitious curse for Heisman Trophy winners entering the NFL. |
Player | Draft class | Position | Team drafted | College | Pick | Summary | Teams played for | Seasons played |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Terry Baker*‡ | 1963 | Quarterback | Los Angeles Rams | Oregon State | Round 1 pick 1 | First overall pick, Heisman Trophy Winner. Threw 0 touchdowns and 4 interceptions. Released after two seasons.[1] | Los Angeles Rams | 2 |
Steve Spurrier+ | 1967 | Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers | Florida | Round 1 pick 3 | Third overall pick, selected before hall-of-fame quarterback Bob Griese. Threw for 40 touchdowns and 60 interceptions.[2] | San Francisco 49ers, Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 9 |
Mike Phipps+ | 1970 | Quarterback | Cleveland Browns | Purdue | Round 1 pick 3 | Third overall pick, Member of the 1969 NCAA All American team. Lack of development saw him benched for Brian Sipe 3 seasons later. Traded for a first round pick in 1977 which became hall-of-famer Ozzie Newsome. Released after 2 seasons with the Bears. | Cleveland Browns, Chicago Bears | 11 |
Walt Patulski* | 1972 | Defensive end | Buffalo Bills | Notre Dame | Round 1 pick 1 | First overall pick, managed 21.5 sacks before career-ending injury as a part of the Cardinals. | Buffalo Bills, St. Louis Cardinals | 5 |
Gary Beban | 1973 | Quarterback | Los Angeles Rams | UCLA | Round 2 pick 30 | Revered All American, draft rights were traded to Washington several weeks later. Benched for hall-of-famer Sonny Jurgensen. | Washington Redskins, Denver Broncos | 3 |
Steve Niehaus† | 1976 | Defensive tackle | Seattle Seahawks | Notre Dame | Round 1 pick 2 | Second overall pick, holds the Seahawk rookie record for sacks in a season with 9½, traded to Minnesota before injuries ended his career. | Seattle Seahawks, Minnesota Vikings | 3 |
Steve Little+ | 1978 | Kicker | St. Louis Cardinals | Arkansas | Round 1 pick 15 | Played with a 48% field goal completion rate, cut after 2 seasons. | Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts, Buffalo Bills | 2 |
Tom Cousineau* | 1979 | Linebacker | Buffalo Bills | Ohio State | Round 1 pick 1 | First overall pick, opted instead to play in the CFL until 1982 before signing with the Browns. Cousineau managed 6.5 sacks before being released by the Browns after 1985. | Cleveland Browns, San Francisco 49ers | 5 |
Jack Thompson+ | 1979 | Quarterback | Cincinnati Bengals | Washington State | Round 1 pick 3 | 2x first team all Pac 8. Drafted to replace Ken Anderson, though poor play and injuries prevented him from further play as the Bengals declined to renew his contract after 1982. | Cincinnati Bengals, Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 5 |
Russell Erxleben+ | 1979 | Kicker | New Orleans Saints | Texas | Round 1 pick 11 | Held NCAA record for longest kick, highest pick ever drafted on a kicker. | San Francisco 49ers, Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 9 |
Johnny "Lam" Jones† | 1980 | Wide receiver | New York Jets | Notre Dame | Round 1 pick 2 | Fastest 100m dash time out of any receivers present at the draft. Despite this, Jones only averaged 20 receptions per season until the Jets traded him to the 49ers, who ultimately cut him after one season. | New York Jets, San Francisco 49ers, Dallas Cowboys | 7 |
Rich Campbell+ | 1981 | Quarterback | Green Bay Packers | California | Round 1 pick 6 | Played in only 7 games before being traded to the Raiders. | Green Bay Packers, Los Angeles Raiders | 4 |
Art Schlichter+ | 1982 | Quarterback | Baltimore Colts | Ohio State | Round 1 pick 4 | The Colts traded up with the Rams to draft Schlichter, though he had a widely known gambling addiction. Later became the first NFL Player in 19 seasons to be banned for involvement with gambling. Threw 3 touchdowns to 11 interceptions before being released by Indianapolis. | Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts, Buffalo Bills | 4 |
Todd Blackledge+ | 1983 | Quarterback | Kansas City Chiefs | Penn State | Round 1 pick 7 | Drafted 10 picks ahead of hall-of-fame Quarterback Dan Marino. Benched in favor of Bill Kenney in Kansas City, remained a backup for his short career. | Kansas City Chiefs, Pittsburgh Steelers | 6 |
Kenny Jackson+ | 1984 | Wide receiver | Philadelphia Eagles | Penn State | Round 1 pick 4 | National Champion with Penn State, only managed 126 receptions. | Philadelphia Eagles, Houston Oilers | 7 |
Mike Junkin+ | 1987 | Defensive tackle | Cleveland Browns | Duke | Round 1 pick 5 | Picked ahead of hall-of-fame cornerback Rod Woodson and pro-bowler Jerome Brown. | Cleveland Browns, Kansas City Chiefs | 2 |
Brian Bosworth+ | 1987 | Linebacker | Seattle Seahawks | Oklahoma | Supplemental draft round 1 | Larger than life image generated much anticipation for Bosworth's playing abilities, 2x Butkus award winner. Despite decent play, Bosworth failed to live up to his own expectations, amplified by media attention. Injuries later ended his career after only 2 seasons as he chose to pursue an acting career. | Seattle Seahawks | 2 |
Aundray Bruce* | 1988 | Outside linebacker | Atlanta Falcons | Auburn | Round 1 pick 1 | First overall pick, 1987 Citrus Bowl MVP. Most recent linebacker selected first overall in NFL history. | Atlanta Falcons, Los Angeles Raiders | 10 |
Tony Mandarich† | 1989 | Offensive tackle | Green Bay Packers | Michigan State | Round 1 pick 2 | Picked between four hall-of-fame players such as Troy Aikman, Barry Sanders, Derrick Thomas, and Deion Sanders. Cut after 3 seasons with Green Bay. | Green Bay Packers, Indianapolis Colts | 5 |
Jeff George* | 1990 | Quarterback | Indianapolis Colts | Illinois | Round 1 pick 1 | Notorious for his toxic personality among numerous teams, spent much of his career as a backup. | Indianapolis Colts, Atlanta Falcons, Oakland Raiders, Minnesota Vikings, Washington Redskins, Seattle Seahawks, Chicago Bears | 15 |
Blair Thomas† | 1990 | Running back | New York Jets | Penn State | Round 1 pick 2 | Part of a supposed curse among Penn State running backs. Spent a majority of his career injured. | New York Jets, New England Patriots, Dallas Cowboys, Atlanta Falcons, Carolina Panthers | 5 |
Andre Ware‡ | 1990 | Quarterback | Detroit Lions | Houston | Round 1 pick 7 | 1989 Heisman Trophy Winner | Detroit Lions, Los Angeles Raiders, Jacksonville Jaguars | 5 |
Dan McGwire+ | 1991 | Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks | San Diego State | Round 1 pick 16 | Threw for 2 touchdowns and 6 interceptions. | Seattle Seahawks, Miami Dolphins | 4 |
Todd Marinovich+ | 1991 | Quarterback | Los Angeles Raiders | USC | Round 1 pick 24 | Dealt with numerous off-field issues stemming from his public feud with his father. Arrested on numerous occasions for | Los Angeles Raiders | 2 |
Steve Emtman* | 1992 | Defensive End | Indianapolis Colts | Illinois | Round 1 pick 1 | 2x Pac 10 defensive player of the year, struggled with injuries throughout his career. | Indianapolis Colts, Washington Redskins | 5 |
David Klingler+ | 1992 | Quarterback | Cincinnati Bengals | Houston | Round 1 pick 6 | Career passer rating of 65.1 with 52% completion rate. | Cincinnati Bengals, Oakland Raiders, Green Bay Packers | 6 |
Rick Mirer† | 1993 | Quarterback | Seattle Seahawks | Notre Dame | Round 1 pick 2 | Predicted by Bill Walsh with heavy comparisons to Joe Montana. Picked behind future pro-bowl QB Drew Bledsoe. Played 3 seasons in Seattle before being traded for a first round pick to the Chicago Bears. Remained as a backup for the duration of his career. | Seattle Seahawks, Chicago Bears, Green Bay Packers, New York Jets, San Francisco 49ers, Oakland Raiders, Detroit Lions | 11 |
Heath Shuler+ | 1994 | Quarterback | Washington Redskins | Tennessee | Round 1 pick 3 | Career passer rating of 65.1 with 52% completion rate. | Washington Redskins, New Orleans Saints, Oakland Raiders | 5 |
Ki-Jana Carter* | 1995 | Running back | Cincinnati Bengals | Penn State | Round 1 pick 1 | Suffered 4 season-ending injuries since drafted, including his 1995 rookie season. | Cincinnati Bengals, Washington Redskins, Green Bay Packers, New Orleans Saints | 9 |
Kyle Brady+ | 1995 | Tight end | New York Jets | Penn State | Round 1 pick 9 | Picked over Warren Sapp much to the anger of Jets fans, underwhelming play led to the Jets choosing not to renew his contract after 3 seasons. | New York Jets, Jacksonville Jaguars, New England Patriots | 12 |
Cedric Jones+ | 1996 | Defensive end | New York Giants | Oklahoma | Round 1 pick 5 | Lack of impact on-field resulted in the Giants declining his fifth year option after the 2000 season. | New York Giants, St. Louis Rams | 5 |
Lawrence Phillips+ | 1996 | Running back | St. Louis Rams | Nebraska | Round 1 pick 6 | Draft pick received by the Rams following the infamous Jerome Bettis trade. Numerous off-field incidents led to several high-profile arrests, culminating in the Rams releasing Phillips during the 1997 season due to misconduct. | St. Louis Rams, Miami Dolphins, San Francisco 49ers | 3 |
Ryan Leaf† | 1998 | Quarterback | San Diego Chargers | Washington State | Round 1 pick 2 | Picked behind future hall-of-fame Quarterback Peyton Manning. Analysts predicted Leaf's athletic capabilities to surpass Manning, though personal issues later led Leaf to play immensely poorly in his only three seasons with the Chargers. Widely considered one of the most notable draft busts in league history. | San Diego Chargers, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Dallas Cowboys, Seattle Seahawks | 4 |
Andre Wadsworth+ | 1998 | Defensive end | Arizona Cardinals | Florida State | Round 1 pick 3 | Spent 2 seasons with Arizona before injuries ended his career. | Arizona Cardinals, New York Jets | 3 |
Lawrence Phillips+ | 1998 | Running back | Chicago Bears | Penn State | Round 1 pick 5 | Numerous injuries and underwhelming play led to the Bears releasing Enis after 3 seasons. | Chicago Bears, Cleveland Browns | 3 |
Tim Couch* | 1999 | Quarterback | Cleveland Browns | Kentucky | Round 1 pick 1 | Aided the expansion Browns franchise to their first postseason appearance since rejoining the league in 1999. Despite this, Couch's career ended due to injury and poor play which saw him benched for backup quarterback Kelly Holcomb. | Cleveland Browns, Green Bay Packers, Jacksonville Jaguars | 6 |
Akili Smith+ | 1999 | Quarterback | Cincinnati Bengals | Oregon | Round 1 pick 3 | Held out of his rookie training camp due to a contract dispute, later ruled out for the duration of the 1999 season stemming from an injury during a preseason game. Released by Cincinnati prior to the 2003 season with 5 touchdowns and 13 interceptions. | Cincinnati Bengals, Green Bay Packers, Tampa Bay Buccaneers | 6 |
Cade McNown+ | 1999 | Quarterback | Cincinnati Bengals | UCLA | Round 1 pick 12 | Part of a 3-way trade between the Bears, Redskins, and Saints to trade up for a quarterback. Later held out for a $6.1 million signing bonus which strained his relationship with his teammates. Poor onfield play later resulted in the Bears trading McNown to the Miami Dolphins prior to the 2001 season. | Chicago Bears, Miami Dolphins, San Francisco 49ers | 3 |
Courtney Brown* | 2000 | Defensive end | Cleveland Browns | Penn State | Round 1 pick 1 | Highest rated defensive prospect in the draft at the time, dealt with numerous injuries that diminished his playing time. | Cleveland Browns, Denver Broncos | 5 |
Peter Warrick+ | 2000 | Wide receiver | Cincinnati Bengals | Florida State | Round 1 pick 4 | Never managed above 700 yards receiving in each of his only 5 seasons in the league, later released prior to the 2005 season. | Cincinnati Bengals, Seattle Seahawks | 5 |
Ron Dayne‡ | 2000 | Running back | New York Giants | Wisconsin | Round 1 pick 11 | 1999 Heisman Trophy winner, all time NCAA rushing record holder. Managed 770 rushing yards his rookie season, though never managed above 700 thereafter. | New York Giants, Denver Broncos, Houston Texans | 7 |
David Carr* | 2002 | Quarterback | Houston Texans | Fresno State | Round 1 pick 1 | First overall pick by expansion Texans franchise in 2002. Later set an NFL record for most times sacked, released after the 2006 season and spent the remainder of his career as a backup. | Houston Texans. | 10 |
Joey Harrington+ | 2002 | Quarterback | Detroit Lions | Oregon | Round 1 pick 3 | Cover Athlete for NCAA Football 2003, Later picked in the first round by Detroit. Organizational mismanagement in Detroit saw a lack of development from Harrington as he threw over 12 interceptions to under 12 touchdowns each season in Detroit; later traded to Miami prior to the 2005 season. | Detroit Lions, Miami Dolphins, Atlanta Falcons, New Orleans Saints | 6 |
Charles Rogers† | 2003 | Wide receiver | Detroit Lions | Michigan State | Round 1 pick 2 | Picked ahead of future 7x pro-bowl receiver Andre Johnson. Rogers later received numerous suspensions from the league for violating substance use protocol. Released prior to the 2006 season. | Detroit Lions | 2 |
Cedric Benson+ | 2005 | Running back | Chicago Bears | Texas | Round 1 pick 4 | Picked fourth overall, later held out his rookie training camp for a larger signing bonus. Later benched for most of the 2005 season, never fully developed for Chicago as he was later released in 2009 after numerous off-field legal issues. | Chicago Bears, Cincinnati Bengals, Green Bay Packers | 7 |
Matt Leinart+ | 2006 | Running back | Arizona Cardinals | USC | Round 1 pick 11 | 2x National Champion, 2004 Heisman trophy winner. Later benched for future hall-of-fame quarterback Kurt Warner. Released after four seasons. | Arizona Cardinals, Houston Texans, Oakland Raiders, Buffalo Bills | 7 |
Tye Hill+ | 2006 | Cornerback | St. Louis Rams | Clemson | Round 1 pick 15 | Member of the 2006 All-Rookie team before suffering numerous injuries during the 2007 season in which the Rams traded Hill to the Falcons. | St. Louis Rams, Atlanta Falcons, Tennessee Titans, Detroit Lions | 4 |
Jamarcus Russell* | 2007 | Quarterback | Oakland Raiders | LSU | Round 1 pick 1 | First overall pick, later held out through training camp for the largest rookie contract in league history worth up to $68 million, with $31.5 million guaranteed. Personal issues and lack of motivation led to poor play on field as Russell threw 18 touchdowns to 23 interceptions before being released by the Raiders prior to the 2010 season. | Oakland Raiders | 3 |
Vernon Gholston+ | 2008 | Defensive end/ Outside linebacker | New York Jets | Ohio State | Round 1 pick 6 | Member of 2007 NCAA All-America team. Lackluster play for the Jets saw Gholston released prior to the 2011 season. | New York Jets, Chicago Bears, St. Louis Rams | 4 |
Jason Smith† | 2009 | Offensive tackle | St. Louis Rams | Baylor | Round 1 pick 2 | Numerous injuries led to Smith being traded to the Jets after 3 seasons with the Rams. | St. Louis Rams, New York Jets, New Orleans Saints | 4 |
Aaron Curry+ | 2009 | Linebacker | Seattle Seahawks | Wake Forest | Round 1 pick 4 | Signed a six-year, $60 million contract including $34 million guaranteed, the largest non-quarterback rookie contract. Underwhelming play led to Curry being benched for then-rookie K. J. Wright. | Seattle Seahawks, Oakland Raiders, New York Giants | 4 |
Mark Sanchez+ | 2009 | Quarterback | New York Jets | USC | Round 1 pick 5 | Member of the 2009 All-Rookie team, part of 2 playoff pushes for the Jets which saw them appear in the AFC Championship game in back-to-back seasons. despite this, Sanchez' play declined severely after 2010, ultimately leading to less time onfield before being released prior to the 2014 season. | New York Jets, Philadelphia Eagles, Denver Broncos, Dallas Cowboys, Chicago Bears, Washington Redskins | 9 |
Jake Locker+ | 2011 | Quarterback | Tennessee Titans | Washington | Round 1 pick 8 | Dismal play saw him benched for most of his duration in the league, Locker later retired prior to the 2015 season due to lack of interest. | Tennessee Titans | 4 |
Blaine Gabbert+ | 2011 | Quarterback | Jacksonville Jaguars | Missouri | Round 1 pick 10 | Benched during his second season in Jacksonville, poor play later saw him traded to San Francisco where it declined even further. Remains a 3rd string backup for the Kansas City Chiefs. | Jacksonville Jaguars, San Francisco 49ers, Arizona Cardinals, Tennessee Titans, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Kansas City Chiefs | (currently active) |
Christian Ponder+ | 2011 | Quarterback | Minnesota Vikings | Florida State | Round 1 pick 12 | Severe lack of development saw Ponder benched for Matt Cassel, and later Sam Bradford before being unsigned in free agency. | Minnesota Vikings, Oakland Raiders, Denver Broncos, San Francisco 49ers | 5 |
Trent Richardson+ | 2012 | Running back | Cleveland Browns | Alabama | Round 1 pick 3 | Seen as the highest rated running back of the draft, later missed time due to injuries before being traded to Indianapolis. | Cleveland Browns, Indianapolis Colts, Oakland Raiders, Baltimore Ravens | 4 |
Justin Blackmon+ | 2012 | Wide receiver | Cleveland Browns | Oklahoma State | Round 1 pick 5 | Member of the 2012 All-rookie team, later suspended indefinitely due to violating league substance use policy, has not played since 2013. | Jacksonville Jaguars | 2 |
Luke Joeckel† | 2013 | Offensive tackle | Jacksonville Jaguars | Texas A&M | Round 1 pick 2 | Rated one of the worst guards in the NFL during his first 2 seasons, plagued by injury before being waived by Jacksonville. | Jacksonville Jaguars, Seattle Seahawks | 4 |
EJ Manuel+ | 2013 | Quarterback | Buffalo Bills | Florida State | Round 1 pick 16 | Benched after 3 seasons despite signing a $8.88 million contract with Buffalo. | Buffalo Bills, Oakland Raiders, Kansas City Chiefs | 6 |
Justin Gilbert+ | 2014 | Cornerback | Cleveland Browns | Oklahoma State | Round 1 pick 8 | Missed his first 2 games due to injury, later traded to Pittsburgh after 2 seasons with Cleveland for a sixth round pick. | Cleveland Browns, Pittsburgh Steelers | 2 |
Johnny Manziel‡ | 2014 | Quarterback | Cleveland Browns | Texas A&M | Round 1 pick 22 | 2012 Heisman Trophy winner. Manziel later received widespread media exposure for his own personal misconduct which immensely affected his onfield play. Manziel was later cut by the Browns prior to the 2016 season. Widely considered one of the biggest busts in league history. | Cleveland Browns | 2 |
Jameis Winston‡* | 2015 | Quarterback | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | Florida State | Round 1 pick 1 | First overall pick, 2013 Heisman trophy winner. Winston struggled with consistent play and legal issues which contributed to him falling out with his teammates. In 2019 he notoriously had a "30-30" season in which he threw 33 touchdowns and 30 interceptions in the same season. | Tampa Bay Buccaneers, New Orleans Saints | (currently active) |
Marcus Mariota‡† | 2015 | Quarterback | Tennessee Titans | Oregon | Round 1 pick 2 | 2014 Heisman Trophy winner. Mariota suffered from injury and a lack of development at the NFL level, though he has remained a backup quarterback since 2018. | Tennessee Titans, Las Vegas Raiders, Atlanta Falcons, Philadelphia Eagles | (currently active) |
Paxton Lynch+ | 2016 | Quarterback | Denver Broncos | Memphis | Round 1 pick 26 | First quarterback selected by Denver following the retirement of hall-of-famer Peyton Manning. Lynch failed to develop and was cut prior to the 2018 season. | Denver Broncos, Seattle Seahawks, Pittsburgh Steelers | 3 |
Mitchell Trubisky† | 2017 | Quarterback | Chicago Bears | North Carolina | Round 1 pick 2 | Picked over pro-bowl quarterbacks Patrick Mahomes and Desean Watson. Failed to develop as a starting QB. | Chicago Bears, Buffalo Bills, Pittsburgh Steelers | (currently active) |
Josh Rosen+ | 2018 | Quarterback | Arizona Cardinals | UCLA | Round 1 pick 10 | Pretentiously claimed there were "nine other mistakes picked ahead of me" following being drafted by the Cardinals. Rosen played poorly throughout his short duration with the Cardinals before being traded for another first round pick (became first overall pick Kyler Murray) from Miami. | Arizona Cardinals, Miami Dolphins, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, San Francisco 49ers, Atlanta Falcons, Cleveland Browns, Minnesota Vikings | 4 |
Clelin Ferrell+ | 2018 | Defensive end | Las Vegas Raiders | Clemson | Round 1 pick 4 | Cut from raiders after 3 seasons. | Las Vegas Raiders, San Francisco 49ers | (currently active) |
Henry Ruggs+ | 2020 | Wide receiver | Las Vegas Raiders | Alabama | Round 1 pick 4 | Arrested and charged with manslaughter following his involvement in a fatal drunk-driving crash which took the life of another motorist. Ruggs was later cut by the Raiders following the arrest and is currently serving time. | Las Vegas Raiders | 2 |
Trey Lance+ | 2021 | Quarterback | San Francisco 49ers | North Dakota State | Round 1 pick 3 | Injuries and lack of development saw him benched for Jimmy Garoppolo. Lance was later traded to Dallas prior to the start of the 2023 season. | San Francisco 49ers, Dallas Cowboys | (currently active) |
References
- ^ "Terry Baker Wins Heisman Trophy".
- ^ "NFL Draft: Gatorswire". 12 April 2021.