Water supply and sanitation in Ghana

From WikiProjectMed
(Redirected from Water pollution in Ghana)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Water supply and sanitation in Ghana
Data
Water coverage (broad definition)78% (2015)[1]
Sanitation coverage (broad definition)14% (2015)[1] (Share of collected wastewater treated: about 10% in Accra[2])
Continuity of supply25% in Accra[3]
Average urban water use (L/person/day)n/a
Average urban water and sanitation tariff (US$/m3)GHS3.01/m3 (US$0.76/m3)[4]
Share of household meteringn/a
Annual investment in WSSUS$0.7 per capita[5]
Share of external financingAbout 90% development assistance[6]
Institutions
Decentralization to municipalitiesIn rural areas: Decentralization to districts, since 1994
National water and sanitation companyYes: Ghana Water Company Limited (GWCL)
Water and sanitation regulatorIn urban areas: Public Utilities Regulatory Commission (PURC)
Responsibility for policy settingMinistry of Sanitation and Water Resources[7]
Sector lawvarious
No. of urban service providers1: GWCL
No. of rural service providersmore than 400 community-managed piped systems[8]

The water supply and sanitation sector in Ghana is a sector that is in charge of the supply of healthy water and also improves the sanitation of water bodies in the country.

In Ghana, the drinking water supply and sanitation sectors face a number of issues, including relatively limited sanitation access, intermittent supply, significant water losses, poor water pressure, and pollution. Since 1994, the sector has been gradually reformed through the creation of an autonomous regulatory agency, introduction of private sector participation, decentralization of the rural supply to 138 districts and increased community participation in the management of rural water systems.[9][10]

An international company has managed all urban water systems since 2006 under a 5-year management contract which expired after achieving only some of its objectives. The reforms also aim at increasing cost recovery and a modernization of the urban utility Ghana Water Company Limited (GWCL).[9] Another problem which partly arose from the recent reforms is the existence of a multitude of institutions with overlapping responsibilities. The National Water Policy (NWP), which was launched at the beginning of 2008, introduced a comprehensive sector policy.[11]

Access

The water supply and sanitation infrastructure is insufficient, especially in rural areas. There are substantial discrepancies between access data from various sources, partially because of different definitions being used by different institutions that are providing access data. According to the Joint Monitoring Program for Water Supply and Sanitation of UNICEF and WHO, access to water and sanitation is as follows:

Urban
(51% of the population)
Rural
(49% of the population)
Total
Water[1] 'At least basic' definition 88% 66% 78%
House connections 33% 3% 18%
Sanitation[1] 'At least basic' definition 19% 9% 14%
Sewerage ? ? ?

According to the United Nations 2015 MDG report, the target of halving the proportion of people without access to safe drinking water has been attained in Ghana.[12] The share of non-functional supply systems in Ghana is estimated at almost one third, with many others operating substantially below designed capacity. Moreover, domestic water supply competes with a rising demand for water by the expanding industry and agriculture sectors.[13]

About 88% of the urban population in Ghana have access to at least basic drinking water.[14] Disparities exist between urban and rural safe drinking water access. According to the Ghana Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey of 2011, urban dwellers are more likely to have access to safe drinking water than the rural dwellers at 91% and 69%, respectively.[14] Consequently, dependency on unsafe water sources is higher in rural areas.[15] The turbidites of most local surface waters in rural areas are greater than 200 NTUs (nephelometric turbidity units) and contain high microbial and fecal contamination, putting children and the rest of the population at high risk for water-related diseases.[16]

Compared to the rest of Ghana, the three northern regions of Ghana are particularly deprived of clean drinking water, with one in ten children dying before their fifth birthday due to some water-related illnesses.[17] In the main Northern Region of Ghana alone, 32% of the 2.5 million residents lack access to improved water sources and must often resort to contaminated drinking-water.[14] Regarding sanitation, only 14% of the total population of Ghana are using an improved sanitation facility as of 2010.[18]

Improved Drinking Water Source Unimproved Drinking Water Source
Household connection Rivers or ponds
Borehole Bucket
Protected dug well Unprotected well
Protected spring Unprotected spring
Public Standpipe Vendor-provided water
Tanker truck water
Bottled (and sachet) water

This table presents the classifications of improved and unimproved water sources in Ghana since the end of the Millennium Development Goals, according to the WHO and UNICEF.[19] As of the end of 2015, improved water sources included household water pipes, boreholes, protected dug wells and springs, and public standpipes.[20]

Service quality

Continuity of supply

According to one estimate, one quarter of the residents in Accra receive a continuous water supply. Approximately 30% are provided water for 12 hours each day, five days a week. Another 35% are supplied for two days each week. The remaining 10% who mainly live on the outskirts of the capital are completely without access to piped water.[3] According to another source, the situation is even worse: In February 2008 some communities within the Accra-Tema metropolis were served either once in a week, once in a fortnight or once in a month.[21]

The continuity of water supply in rural areas and the Northern Region of Ghana are less frequent. Particularly in rural areas, locals are forced to fetch their own water from a variety of water sources depending on location:[16]

  • Tube wells or boreholes – a deep hole that has been driven, bored or drilled to reach ground water. The water is delivered by tube through a pump that is powered by a human, and the well is protected by a platform to prevent run-offs or bird droppings into the water.
  • Protected dug well – well protected from runoff water by a well lining or casing raised above ground level.
  • Rainwater collection – rain that is collected or harvested from surfaces and stored in a container for use.
  • Water tank truck – water is trucked into a community and sold from the truck.
  • Unprotected dug wells or springs – a well not protected from runoff or bird droppings.
  • Cart with small tank/drum – water is sold by a provider who transports water into a community. Transportation is done by donkey carts or motoking.
  • Surface water sources – rivers, dams, lakes, ponds, etc. All of them are really likely to be polluted, which will be dangerous for the people who drink from there. These are the most dangerous sources of water for the population in Ghana, since they may have so many bacteria and toxic product in them that the people will get infections and diseases, some of which could even kill[22] ly.

Water contamination

Drinking water quality

The Fecal-oral disease route transmission.

The lack of clean drinking water and sanitation systems is a severe public health concern in Ghana, contributing to 70% of diseases in Ghana. Despite significant strive by the government and its developing partners, about 76% of households risk drinking water contaminated with animal and human excreta.[23] Widespread use of plastic drinking water sachets due to lack of available potable water has also led to increased plastic pollution, often polluting water bodies, choking stormwater drains and causing death of livestock.[24] The country's gold mining industry has polluted 60% of Ghana's waters.[25]

Due to unclean water and improper sanitation, Ghana has 1,000 children under five years old dying each year from diarrhea, caused by polluted water.[26] The water that they get from ponds, lakes or rivers is of bad quality. Consequently, households without access to clean water are forced to use less reliable and hygienic sources, and often pay more.[27]

Contaminated drinking water, along with poor sanitation, are linked to transmission of water-related diseases such as cholera, diarrhoea, dysentery, hepatitis A, typhoid and polio.[28] Due to drinking contaminated water, diarrheal disease is the third most commonly reported illness at health centers across Ghana. 25% of all deaths in children under the age of five are attributed to diarrhea.[29] In addition to lack of sanitation infrastructure, some cultural beliefs and views encourage open defecation. Of the total population in Ghana, 23% use open defecation as their sanitation facility.[14] As many as 72% of people in the Northern Region open defecate, making it the region with the highest prevalence of open defecation in Ghana[14]

The majority of waterborne illnesses are enteric diseases (i.e. intestinal diseases) transmitted through the fecal-oral route.[30] In the transmission pathways of disease through water contamination, human feces from public defecation end up in water sewages and non-recycling latrines, which is then collected in the local surface waters by rainfall and ingested by local inhabitants through direct exposure, absorption and ingestion. Surface waters are the main drinking-water source for the communities of Northern Region, Ghana.[16]

Effects on education

The main traditional sources of water in many parts of rural Ghana are small ponds and unprotected wells, both of which are really easily polluted, causing diseases to the people who drink it (Oxfam). More than 50% of the rural population in Ghana also rely on unsafe water resources from vendors (Ghana Clean Water Project). This brings many diseases. The water contains parasites and a high microbial content, as well as dangerous minerals. Many people, mostly children, suffer from many diseases caused by this water, and some of them may even be deadly.[31]

Not only does this water affect people's health, it also affects education. For example, in some places in Ghana, children, mostly girls, are denied their right to go to school because their schools don't have private sanitation facilities. Instead, they are expected to spend the whole day fetching water. This affects their education and makes it harder for the country to develop faster. If the people had more clean water resources and sanitation the girls wouldn't be denied their right to go to school, therefore, they would have an education and would increase the number of educated people in Ghana. All things considered, the water issues that Ghana is dealing with doesn't only affect the population with disease, but it also affects with the education. This does not happen too often, but it happens in some parts of Ghana, usually rural areas.[31]

Wastewater treatment

It is estimated that in 2000 the urban areas of Ghana generated about 763,698 m3 of wastewater each day, resulting in approximately 280 million m3 over the entire year. Regional capitals count for another 180 million m3.[32] Only a small share of the generated urban wastewater is collected, and an even smaller share is being treated. Inadequate management of urban, industrial and agricultural wastewater often means that the drinking-water of millions of people is either dangerously contaminated or chemically polluted.[28]

In the capital city Accra, the share of wastewater collected is approximately 10%. Moreover, less than 25% of the 46 industrial and municipal treatment plants in Ghana were functional according to an inventory undertaken by the Ghana Environmental Protection Agency in 2001. Treatment plants for municipal wastewater are operated by local governments, and most of them are stabilization ponds.[33] A biological treatment plant has been built in the late 1990s at Accra's Korle Lagoon. However, it only handles about 8% of Accra's wastewater.[2]

Water resources

Ghana is well endowed with water resources. The Volta river system basin, consisting of the Oti, Daka, Pru, Sene and Afram rivers as well as the white and Black Volta rivers, covers 70% of the country area. Another 22% of Ghana is covered by the southwestern river system watershed comprising the Bia, Tano, Ankobra and Pra rivers. The coastal river system watershed, comprising the Ochi-Nawuka, Ochi Amissah, Ayensu, Densu and Tordzie rivers, covers the remaining 8% of Ghana.

Furthermore, groundwater is available in mesozoic and cenozoic sedimentary rocks and in sedimentary formations underlying the Volta basin. The Volta Lake, with a surface of 8,500 km², is one of the world's largest artificial lakes. In all, the total actual renewable water resources are estimated to be 53.2 billion m³ per year.[34]

Panorama and landscape view of Lake Volta in Volta Basin and Eastern Region of Ghana. Lake Volta by artificial surface area is the largest reservoir, lake, and artificial lake on Earth. Lake Volta drains into the Gulf of Guinea on the Atlantic Ocean. Volta River has three main tributaries—the Black Volta, White Volta and Red Volta.

Water use

In 2000, total water withdrawal was 982 million m³, of which two-thirds were used for agricultural purposes. Another 10% was withdrawn for industry, leaving 24% or 235 million m³ for domestic use. Furthermore, 37,843 km³ are used for hydroelectricity generation at the Akosombo Dam each year.[35]

History and recent developments

Archaeological work in the house ruins of Begho (12th–19th century) have revealed the existence of cisterns which were on average, two meters deep.[36] In 1817, Thomas Edward Bowdich documented upon the sanitation methods in the Ashanti Empire including the prevalence of latrines across the houses of Kumasi.

What surprised me most... was the discovery that every house had its cloacae (latrine), besides the common ones for the lower orders without the town. They were generally situated under a small archway in the most retired angle of the building, but not unfrequently upstairs, within a separate room like a small closet where the large hollow pillar also assists to support the upper story: the holes are of small circumference, but dug to a surprising depth, and boiling water is daily poured down, which effectually prevents the least offence....

— Bowdich, 1817.[37]

In 1821, William Hutton confirmed Bowdich's observations.

Mr. Bowdich's observations regarding the houses being provided with cloacaes and the general cleanliness of the Ashantees are correct; and there can be no doubt that in the arrangement of their dwellings they are superior to many of their neighbours....

— Hutton, 1821.[37]

Bowdich recorded in the early 19th century, that rubbish and waste from all houses were burnt every morning behind the streets. According to scholar Donna Maier, a Public Works Department existed in the Ashanti Empire under the stool called Akwammofo Akonnwa. This department was responsible for cleaning the streets of Kumasi daily and it ensured that the people had kept their compounds clean and weeded.[37][38]

In 1928, the first piped water supply system was constructed at Cape Coast. The Water Supply Division of the Public Works Department was responsible for the service provision in rural and urban areas of Ghana. After Ghana's independence in 1957, the division was separated from the Public Works Department and placed under the Ministry of Works and Housing. In 1965, it was transformed into the Ghana Water and Sewerage Corporation (GWSC), a legal public utility responsible for the provision of urban and rural water supply for public, domestic, and industrial purposes as well as the establishment, operation, and control of sewerage systems.

Decentralization, focus on rural areas and independent regulation (1994–1999)

In the mid-1990s, under the Presidency of Jerry Rawlings and after the passing of a new democratic Constitution in 1992, the government of Ghana enacted five key laws that affected the responsibility for water supply and sanitation:

  • The Local Government Act No. 462 of 1993 defined the use of powers of District Assemblies as the highest political authority in each District, headed by a District Chief Executive (similar to a mayor). Neither the constitution nor the Local Government Act clearly define the responsibilities of District Assemblies, and initially they had no role in water supply and sanitation until they were partially transferred to them in 1999.
  • The Water Resources Commission Act No. 552 of 1996 created the Water Resources Commission (WRC) that was made responsible for integrated water resources management including permits for water abstraction.[39]
  • The Public Utilities and Regulatory Commission Act No. 538 of 1997 created the Public Utilities and Regulatory Commission (PURC) that was made responsible for the regulation of the electricity sector and urban water supply, including the review of requests for tariff increases, the monitoring of service quality and the protection of consumers.[27]
  • The Community Water and Sanitation Agency Act No. 564 of 1998 created the Community Water and Sanitation Agency (CWSA) that became responsible for the support of local communities and District Assemblies in terms of rural water supply and sanitation. The CWSA emerged from the Community Water and Sanitation Division that had been created as a semi-autonomous division of GWSC in 1994.[40]
  • Under the provisions of the Statutory Corporations (Conversion to Companies) Act 461 of 1993 and in line with a government policy to transform state corporations into companies operated on a commercial basis, GWSC was transformed into a company called GWCL, which remained responsible for urban water supply only, while responsibility for sewer systems was transferred to the District Assemblies.[41]

In 1999, the responsibility to support communities in the provision of water supply and sanitation in more than 110 small towns and in rural areas was transferred to the District Assemblies. Sanitation also became a responsibility of the District Assemblies, both in urban and rural areas.[3] Furthermore, the government pursued private sector participation in urban water supply with the assistance of the World Bank through preparatory studies and workshops, but without actually bringing in the private sector yet.

Private sector participation in urban areas (2000–2011)

To carry out the private sector participation of GWCL, originally a 10-year lease contract was envisaged. In 2000, a lease contract between GWCL and the US company Azurix failed due to public opposition and accusations of corruption which led to the formation of the Coalition against Water Privatization.[42] In October 2006, under the Presidency of John Kufuor and with the support of the World Bank-funded Urban Water Project (see below) a five-year management contract was signed between the GWCL and Aqua Vitens Rand Limited (AVRL), a consortium of the Dutch public water company Vitens and the South African public company Rand Water. The main objectives of the 5-year management contract were:

  • Improving the reliability (pressure and flow rate) and quality of potable water,
  • Ensuring the company's financial sustainability,
  • Improving customer service, and
  • Providing access to potable water at affordable prices to low income consumers.[43][44] In 2008 severe water shortages in Accra were reported due to power outages at two water treatment plants.[45] The management contract expired in June 2011 without being renewed after having achieved its objectives only partially.

In rural areas, the powers and resources of District Assemblies were strengthened through the Local Government Service Act 656 of 2003. The Act transferred the power to appoint, promote and discipline civil servants from the national government to the District Assemblies. In 2006 a Districts Development Fund was created to channel central government and donor funds in a transparent and effective way to District Assemblies. An Environmental, Health and Sanitation Directorate was created in the Ministry of Local Governments and Rural Development in 2009 to focus more on sanitation. In this context a program was launched to eliminate open defecation through community-led total sanitation.[46]

Responsibility for water supply and sanitation

The Pra River system of the rivers of Ghana.

According to a multi-donor review of Ghana's water supply sector, it is "quite well structured", with the government in charge of policy and regulation, while the private sector and communities play important roles in service delivery.[47] The institutional framework for sanitation is much less clear, with responsibilities not being clearly defined.

Policy and regulation

At the moment, a number of institutions exist to supervise and regulate water supply and sanitation. The policy framework is based on the Ghana Poverty Reduction Strategy (GPRS).[48]

General water sector policies for both rural and urban areas are set by the Water Directorate within the Ministry of Water Resources, Works and Housing (MWRWH). Furthermore, the ministry solicits funding from external support agencies, monitors the sector, and advises the Cabinet.[39] The Water Sector Restructuring Secretariat, created in 1997 in the Ministry of Water Resources, Works and Housing, oversees the process of private sector participation in the sector.[49]

The Ministry of Local Government and Rural Development shares responsibility for setting sanitation policies and coordinating funding for the subsector with MWRWH. The government promotes decentralization so that sanitation policies are expected to be carried out by Metropolitan, Municipal, and District Assemblies. To enforce environmental quality laws, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) under the Ministry of Environment and Science is expected to examine the impact of sanitation development activities on the environment.

To overcome the lack of coordination between the numerous sector institutions, the Minister of Water Resources, Works, and Housing, Abubakar Saddique Boniface, launched a National Water Policy (NWP) in February 2008, which covers water resources management, water supply and sanitation. Although the sector has made progress, a lack of coherence in policy formulation resulted in a multitude of implementation strategies. The NWP aimed to formulate a comprehensive sector policy and to make it easier for development partners to provide the necessary support to the sector.[50] The NWP had been prepared by the Water Resources Commission (WRC) since 2002.[11]

Service provision

Urban areas

The Ghana Water Company Ltd. (GWCL) is responsible for providing, distributing, and conserving water for domestic, public, and industrial purposes in 82 urban systems in localities with more than 5,000 inhabitants. Local private companies are in charge of meter installation, customer billing, and revenue collection.[51] Urban sanitation is a responsibility of local governments.[52]

Rural areas

A Rope pump close to Paga, Upper East Region.

The Community Water and Sanitation Agency (CWSA) is in charge of coordinating and facilitating the implementation of the National Community Water and Sanitation Programme (NCWSP) in rural areas, which is carried out directly by the communities and their District Assemblies. The NCWSP focuses on three main objectives to achieve health improvements: safe water supply, hygiene education, and improved sanitation.[53]

The CWSA was created in 1994 under the framework of the Ghana decentralization policy and became autonomous in 1998. The institution does not directly construct, operate, and maintain facilities for water supply and sanitation. Instead, its role is to coordinate the work of a number of actors which carry out the services in rural areas, including public sector organizations, local beneficiary communities, private sector organizations, and NGOs. The CWSA is also expected to ensure that financial support from development partners is effectively used and to ensure hygiene education. The agency operates ten regional offices besides its head office in Accra.[54]

In communities with fewer than 5,000 inhabitants, water supply systems are owned and managed by the respective community on a demand-driven basis. According to the NCWSP, these systems do not receive any cross-subsidies and 5% of investment costs are paid by District Assemblies.[55] Communities and in rural areas and small towns elect gender-balanced water and sanitation boards consisting of volunteers, including one or two village-based caretakers who received special training in repair and maintenance.[39][56] Communities can contract private companies or NGOs to provide technical assistance, goods, or services.[57]

Local companies drill boreholes and build hand-dug wells, and local artisans are used to provide household latrines.[51] Maintenance units of CWSA have been privatized and the regional companies created through this process now perform major repairs on behalf of District Assemblies. Minor repairs are carried out by area mechanics.[58] The communities' water and sanitation boards receive technical assistance by District Water and Sanitation Teams (DWST), ideally consisting of an engineer, a hygiene expert, and a community mobilizer.[56] However, in some districts these teams are so weak that the regional teams of CWSA resort to providing direct assistance to local water and sanitation boards.[46]

Other stakeholders

The Ghana Coalition of NGOs in Water and Sanitation (CONIWAS), created in 2001, "works in partnership with sector players to influence policies, remove barriers and promote access to potable water, sanitation and improved hygiene for the poor and vulnerable." According to the coalition, giving NGOs one voice for advocacy and lobbying has been one of its major benefits.[59]

Innovations for Poverty Action

Innovations for Poverty Action (IPA) was founded in 2002 as a research and policy non-profit organization that aims to discover and promote effective solutions to global poverty issues. IPA recruits researchers and decision-makers to measure the impacts of interventions in the areas of agriculture, education, health, financial inclusion, governance, peace & recovery, small & medium enterprises, and social protection among 18 country programs.[60] Randomized Control Trials (RCT) and other forms of qualitative research are conducted to achieve this, including the Clean Water in Northern Ghana research study.[61] This study assesses the willingness of households in Northern Ghana to purchase the Kosim filter that is sold by Pure Home Water (PHW), a Ghana-based NGO. The study also aims to measure the health effects of household-level water treatment in areas whose populations have a high risk of waterborne disease.[62]

Pure Home Water

Pure Home Water (PHW) is a Ghana-based NGO and a social enterprise.[63] Founded in 2005, PHW was designed to be a manufacturer of ceramic pot water filters located in the northern city of Tamale, Ghana. Its two goals include delivering aid to the people most in need of safe drinking water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) in Northern Ghana, and to become financially and locally self-sustaining. This is accomplished by providing training and monitoring of correct, consistent and continuous (3Cs) use of the AfriClay filter. They also build and disseminate hand-washing stations and sanitation facilities throughout villages in the Northern Region. PHW is a partnered organization of Innovations for Poverty Action.[64][65]

Saha Global

Saha Global (formerly known as Community Water Solutions) is a Boston, Massachusetts-based nonprofit founded in 2008 that aims to meet the water and energy needs of Ghanaian communities in the Northern Region. Saha Global works to empower the women of rural Ghanaian communities to provide access to clean water and electricity through the provision of business opportunities. This is accomplished by bringing young leaders from throughout the world to Ghana through its Global Leadership Program. While in Ghana, participants train local women to build businesses which can channel revenue back into their local communities. As of 2016, 84 clean water businesses and 20 solar electric businesses have been created with the aid of Saha Global, and 100% of these businesses are in full operation to date.[66]

Water.org

Water.org is an American and international nonprofit developmental aid organization designed to deliver access to safe water and sanitation around the world by pioneering innovative and sustainable solutions to the global water crisis. This organization was founded in 1990 after the merging of two water NGOs: H2O Africa, co-founded by Matt Damon, and WaterPartners, co-founded by Gary White. Through its efforts in making water and sanitation safe, accessible and cost-effective, Water.org has continued to deliver aid to more than four million lives around the world for over 25 years.[67]

Currently, Water.org is working in two rural areas in Ghana: Volta Region and Upper East Region. These districts are among the poorest of the country, with less than half of the population having little access to safe drinking water and fewer families having access to improved sanitation. Additionally, the rural communities in these regions suffer greatly from waterborne diseases, including diarrhea. Water.org works with local communities and partner organizations, such as Rural Aid, to construct wells, latrines and biosand filters in Ghana as well as to provide health and hygiene education.[68][69]

Efficiency of utilities

Non-revenue water

According to the Water Sector Restructuring Secretariat non-revenue water in urban areas stands at approximately 50% of the produced water, i.e. it is lost, among other things, due to leakage and illegal connections.[70] According to a Ghanaian radio station, a survey showed that 3,000 out of 15,000 connections were illegal while 20 minor leaks were found.[71] Furthermore, most of those connected to water supply do not pay their bills.[72] At least at the end of the 1990s, the Ghanaian government participated in that poor payment culture.[73]

As part of the efforts to reduce system losses, in February 2008 the Accra East Region of AVRL-GWCL has caused the arrest of ten illegal connection syndicates in the Adenta community. They had constructed huge underground reservoirs which served as a source of water for private water tanker operators. The tanker operators buy water from these illegal sources and sell it to private individuals at Ashaley Botwe at high prices.[74]

Labor productivity

It is estimated that in 2010, GWCL had 7.2 per 1,000 connections. This figure is in line with regional levels.[43] However, international good practice is less than 4 employees per 1,000 connections.

Financial aspects

Tariffs and cost recovery

Water tariffs in Ghana are too low to recover the costs of the service. Water tariffs in rural areas tend to be higher than in urban areas.

Urban areas. In December 2015 the regulator PURC approved a 67.2% increase in urban water tariffs. Tariffs were increased from GHS1.78/m3 ($0.45/m3) to GHS3.01/m3 (US$0.76/m3). The average monthly bill for a family of five will reach GHS10.00 ($2.50). Ghana Water had requested a 400% tariff increase to fully cover costs, but the regulator had pared down the request substantially, citing concerns about affordability.[4] Between 1990 and 1997, the average water tariff in Ghana's urban areas had been in the range of US$0.10 to US$0.15 per m³.[75][76]

At that time, the Government was not willing to approve major tariff increases. The situation changed with the creation of the regulatory agency PURC which autonomously examines and approves public service tariffs, resulting in an average water tariff of about US$0.50 in 2004.[73] In 2006, GWCL's tariff for the first 20m³ consumed was US$0.55 per m³, whereas US$0.76 were charged for each m³ exceeding 20m³ within a month.[75][76] Subsequently, the USD equivalent of tariffs decreased again with the local currency losing in value.

Rural areas. According to the CWSA's policy, the water tariff in rural areas should recover the supply cost of the service, including operation, maintenance, major repairs, replacements, and extension to new areas. Tariffs are set by the District Assemblies in rural areas.[39] However, the supply cost should be low enough to not result in a tariff of more than US$1 per m³. A study conducted in five community-managed piped systems in the Ashanti Region found an average tariff of about US$0.60 per m³ in 2003, which actually covers between 57 and 77% of the full supply cost.[77]

Another study which was carried out in 2005 indicates an average monthly expenditure for water of US$0.99 in 97 sample villages in the Volta Region and US$0.89 in 103 villages in the Brong Ahafo Region per household. However, in nearly 70% of the villages in Volta and only 40% of the villages in Brong Ahafo, at least 90% of the interviewed households actually paid for water. Where water use is charged, it is done through a fixed system or a pay-as-you-fetch system.[78]

Investment and financing

Since economic efficiency as well as cost recovery in the sector are extremely low, financing water and sanitation investments in Ghana relies heavily on external funding. According to one estimate 90% of the total investment in the sector in the 1990s was made by external agencies,[6] which contributed about US$500 million for the sector between 1990 and 2003. It is worth mentioning that sanitation generally receives much less attention.[79] According to another estimate, more than 96% of expected financing in 2006 will be from external donors.[47]

Despite the strong engagement of international donors, funding remains insufficient to achieve the Millennium Development Goals for water and sanitation, aiming at halving the share of the population without access to these services by 2015 compared to 1990. According to one estimate, the expansion and rehabilitation of urban infrastructure requires investments of US$1.3 billion over an unspecified period.[27] Annual investment needs in water supply and sanitation are estimated by another source at US$150 million. Expected investment funding for 2006 was US$85 million, or 57% of the needs.[47]

Actual annual investments in urban areas have been estimated by the Water Sector Restructuring Secretariat at around US$40 million per year, having "recently" declined to only US$17 million per year (without specifying which year). The US$40m figure for urban areas corresponds to about US$4 per capita, an average level compared to other low-income countries.[80]

Private investments were mobilized through a Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) project for a seawater desalination plant in Accra. The 25-year contract for the financing, construction and operation of a 60,000 cubic meter per day plant was awarded in 2012. Water will be sold at US$1.36/cubic meter to GWCL, with a guarantee from the Ministry of Finance. The World Bank subsidiary MIGA insures the package against political risk. Funding comes from the South African Standard Bank (US$88.7m) and the shareholder Abengoa Water ($38.1m). GWCL ruled out further desalination projects citing the country's abundant water resources and the need to quickly find a solution for the quickly growing Nungua area where the plant will be located.[81]

The International Finance Corporation (IFC) supports the Asutsuare Water Treatment Plant, a 500 million Euro Build, Own, Operate and Transfer (BOOT) project with GWCL developed by the Belgian contractor Denys. It includes a water treatment plant with a capacity of 432,000 m3/day, located downstream from the Kpong Dam on the Volta River and two pipelines, each of approximately 73 km to Grand Accra, as well as two water reservoirs.[82]

International cooperation

Major donors active in water supply and sanitation in Ghana are the African Development Bank, Canada, Denmark, the EU Commission, France, Germany, Japan, the Netherlands, and the World Bank. There is a Multi-Donor Budgetary Support Mechanism, a Water and Sanitation Sector Group as well as Joint Sector Annual Review Conferences between the government and its "development partners" (donors).[46]

African Development Bank

The African Development Bank contributes to the Accra Sewerage Improvement Project (ASIP) with a loan of US$69 million, while the Government of Ghana provides US$8.6 million. The project was approved by the ADB in 2006 and is expected to be implemented within five years. In this time, two treatment plants and eight pumping stations are expected to be built. Moreover, sewerage networks and sanitation facilities will be extended and rehabilitated. The project also supports environmental measures, institutional strengthening, engineering services, and project management.[83]

Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA)

The Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) supports the water supply and sanitation sector in Ghana's northern regions through three projects:

  1. CIDA contributes US$11 million to the gender-balanced District Capacity Building Project (DISCAP), which aims at strengthening local capacities to manage water and sanitation resources, thus enabling local government bodies to provide water supply and sanitation services. DISCAP began in 2000 and will end in 2008.[84]
  2. The agency provides US$16.4 million for the Northern Region Water Sanitation Project (NORWASP), which began in 1999 and is expected to end in 2009. The main objective of the gender-balanced project is to increase access to water and sanitation through a demand-driven approach. At the end of the project, up to 250,000 communities in the eastern corridor section of the northern region are expected to have access to safe drinking water, including 420 which independently manage their new water systems.[85]
  3. The Northern Region Small Towns (NORST) project, which is being implemented from 2004 to 2014, is supported by CIDA with US$30 million. The project is expected to establish water supply and sanitation services in up to 30 small towns.[86]

Germany

Germany supports rural water supply and sanitation as part of its support for Ghana's decentralization program. Together with other donors Germany supports the District Development Facility since 2009, established under the lead of the Ministry of Local Government and Rural Development. Until 2014, Germany cofinances up to 36 million euros of a total 210 million euros. The remainder is financed by other donors and the Ghanaian Government, which provides a third of the funding. The District Development Facility provides funds to District Assemblies that have to follow strict rules concerning transparency and accountability which are independently monitored. Districts that manage their funds well also receive more funds.[87]

A previous rural water supply project supported by Germany was rated satisfactorily in an ex-post evaluation conducted in 2005. The evaluation found, among other things, that three to eight years after their construction only 4 percent of the wells had fallen completely in disuse, while 76 percent were functioning and 20 percent were temporarily out of order. The evaluation also found that in 28 percent of water samples the iron content was high and that water from other sources than the wells built under the project was still used for various purposes, including drinking.[58]

World Bank

The World Bank supports both rural and urban water supply in Ghana.

Community Water and Sanitation Program (CWSP) The Second Community Water and Sanitation Program was initiated in 2000 with support of a World Bank IDA credit of US$21.9 million, aiming at increasing access and supporting effective and sustained use of improved community water supply and sanitation services in villages and small towns through a demand-driven approach. It built on lessons learned from the first Community Water and Sanitation Program which had been carried out from 1994 to 2000.[88]

A large-scale decentralization approach in the planning, implementation, and management of water supply and sanitation in Ghana was one of the main characteristics of the second program. Moreover, the communities were given technical assistance and hygiene education. Gender-balanced water and sanitation committees were set up to actively engage and include NGOs, private sector actors, and District Assemblies. As a result of the program, which ended in 2004, nearly 800,000 people were provided with potable water and almost 6,000 households and 440 schools were provided with latrines.[88]

Small Towns Water Supply and Sanitation Project The Small Towns Water Supply and Sanitation Project was approved by the World Bank in 2004 with a loan of US$26 million. In 2007 the World Bank decided to support the project with an additional credit of US$10 million. The German development agency GTZ contributes to the project with US$400,000, while the Government of Ghana provides US$4.6 million.

The project will end in 2009 and aims at increasing water supply and sanitation access to small towns in six Ghanaian regions, providing about 500,000 people with water supply facilities and about 50,000 people with sanitary facilities. Therefore, the project supports the planning, construction, and rehabilitation of water and sanitation systems in small towns and provides hygiene promotion, training, and technical assistance. In addition, the CWSA is supported by a management fee equal to 5% of the funds disbursed to support the incremental costs of the project.[89]

Urban Water Project In 2004, the World Bank's Board approved a credit of US$103 million for the Urban Water Project, which was later turned into a grant. The Nordic Development Fund contributes another US$5 million, while the Government of Ghana provides the remaining US$12 million of the US$120 million project.[90]

The main objectives of the program, which will end in 2010, are to (i) significantly increase access to water supply systems in the urban areas of Ghana with an emphasis on improving the service for the urban poor; and (ii) restoring the long-term financial stability, viability, and sustainability of the GWCL. It provides technical assistance and training. Moreover, the Urban Water Project supports private sector participation and thus contributed to the management contract between GWCL and AVRL.[91]

References

  1. ^ a b c d World Health Organization; UNICEF. "Joint Monitoring Program for Water Supply and Sanitation (JMP)". Archived from the original on 16 February 2008. Retrieved 15 August 2012.
  2. ^ a b Adu-Ahyiah, Maxwell; Anku, Romi Ernest. Small Scale Wastewater Treatment in Ghana (a Scenario) (PDF). Lund. Archived from the original (PDF) on 22 September 2007. Retrieved 28 March 2008., p. 1-2
  3. ^ a b c WaterAid. "National Water Sector Assessment, Ghana" (PDF). Retrieved 26 March 2008.[permanent dead link], p. 2
  4. ^ a b "Ghana swallows 67% tariff hike". Global Water Intelligence. December 2015. p. 13. {{cite web}}: Missing or empty |url= (help)
  5. ^ WaterAid. "National Water Sector Assessment, Ghana" (PDF). Retrieved 26 March 2008.[permanent dead link], p. 3. According to the source annual investments for an unspecified year (or average of years) are US$17m. Ghana has 26m inhabitants.
  6. ^ a b African Development Fund (October 2005). "Accra Sewerage Improvement Project (ASIP). Appraisal Report" (PDF). Retrieved 28 March 2008. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)[dead link], p. 6
  7. ^ "Ministry of Sanitation and Water Resources (MSWR) (Ghana) | Devex".
  8. ^ Nyarko, K. B.; Oduro-Kwarteng, S.; Adama, I. (2006). "Cost recovery of community-managed piped water systems in the Ashanti region, Ghana". Water and Environment Journal. 21 (2). Chartered Institution of Water and Environmental Management (CIWEM): 92–99. doi:10.1111/j.1747-6593.2006.00051.x. ISSN 1747-6585. S2CID 154378574., p. 93
  9. ^ a b WaterAid. "National Water Sector Assessment, Ghana" (PDF). Retrieved 26 March 2008.[permanent dead link]
  10. ^ "Scaling up Water and Sanitation in Ghana". World Bank. Retrieved 13 September 2023.
  11. ^ a b Ghanaian Water Resources Commission. "National Water Policy". Archived from the original on 2 June 2008. Retrieved 26 March 2008.
  12. ^ "2015 Ghana Millennium Development Goals Report". UNDP in Ghana. Retrieved 6 May 2016.
  13. ^ "Ghana". Safe Water Network. Safe Water Network. Retrieved 29 April 2016.
  14. ^ a b c d e "Ghana Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey 2011" (PDF).
  15. ^ "Ghana – Water Crisis | Water.org". Water.org. Retrieved 6 May 2016.
  16. ^ a b c Mintz, Eric; Bartram, Jamie; Lochery, Peter; Wegelin, Martin (1 October 2001). "Not Just a Drop in the Bucket: Expanding Access to Point-of-Use Water Treatment Systems". American Journal of Public Health. 91 (10): 1565–1570. doi:10.2105/ajph.91.10.1565. ISSN 0090-0036. PMC 1446826. PMID 11574307.
  17. ^ "Ghana – Where We Work – WaterAid America". www.wateraid.org. Retrieved 6 May 2016.
  18. ^ "UNICEF. 2012. Pneumonia and Diarrhoea – Tackling the deadliest diseases for the world's poorest children" (PDF).
  19. ^ "WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply and Sanitation (2008). A Snapshot of Drinking Water and Sanitation in Africa" (PDF).
  20. ^ "United Nations. 2015. Ghana Millennium Development Goals Report" (PDF).
  21. ^ AVRL: The Dodowa intervention
  22. ^ "Ghana". WSUP. WSUP. Retrieved 27 April 2016.
  23. ^ "Water, Sanitation and Hygiene | UNICEF Ghana". www.unicef.org. Retrieved 28 September 2023.
  24. ^ Adam, Issahaku; Walker, Tony R.; Bezerra, Joana Carlos; Clayton, Andrea (1 June 2020). "Policies to reduce single-use plastic marine pollution in West Africa". Marine Policy. 116: 103928. doi:10.1016/j.marpol.2020.103928. S2CID 216397079.
  25. ^ "The illegal gold mines killing rivers and livelihoods in Ghana," 11 August 2021, BBC News, retrieved 11 August 2021
  26. ^ "Water Aid- Where we work: Ghana". Water Aid UK. Retrieved 10 May 2018.
  27. ^ a b c Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). "African Economic Outlook 2007 – Ghana Country Note" (PDF). Retrieved 25 March 2008. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help), p. 294
  28. ^ a b "Drinking-water". World Health Organization. Archived from the original on 8 August 2014. Retrieved 6 May 2016.
  29. ^ "UNICEF. 2012. Pneumonia and Diarrhoea – Tackling the deadliest diseases for the world's poorest children" (PDF).
  30. ^ "WHO. 2006. Preventing disease through healthy environments" (PDF).
  31. ^ a b "Ghana". Water.org. Water.org. Retrieved 27 April 2016.
  32. ^ Agodzo, SK; Huibers, FP; Chenini, F.; van Lier, JB; Duran A. Use of wastewater in irrgigated agriculture. Country studies from Bolivia, Ghana and Tunisia. Volume 2: Ghana (PDF). Wageningen: WUR. ISBN 90-6754-704-2. Retrieved 28 March 2008., p. 16-17
  33. ^ RUAF Ghana sanitation report
  34. ^ Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. "Ghana Country Overview" (PDF). Retrieved 25 March 2008. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help), p. 3-4
  35. ^ Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. "Ghana Country Overview" (PDF). Retrieved 25 March 2008. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help), p. 4-5
  36. ^ Posnansky, Merrick (2015). "Begho: Life and Times". Journal of West African History. 1 (2): 95–118. doi:10.14321/jwestafrihist.1.2.0095. ISSN 2327-1868. S2CID 193121437.
  37. ^ a b c Maier, D. (1979). "Nineteenth-Century Asante Medical Practices". Comparative Studies in Society and History. 21 (1): 63–81. doi:10.1017/S0010417500012652. JSTOR 178452. PMID 11614369. S2CID 19587869.
  38. ^ Feierman, Steven (1985). "Struggles for Control: The Social Roots of Health and Healing in Modern Africa". African Studies Review. 28 (2/3): 73–147. doi:10.2307/524604. JSTOR 524604.
  39. ^ a b c d WaterAid. "National Water Sector Assessment, Ghana" (PDF). Retrieved 26 March 2008.[permanent dead link], p. 5
  40. ^ Ghanaian Water Resources and Environmental Sanitation Project. "Water Supply & Sanitation in Ghana". Retrieved 26 March 2008.
  41. ^ United Nations (2004). "Freshwater Country Profile: Ghana" (PDF). Retrieved 7 April 2008. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help), p. 2
  42. ^ Rahaman, Abu Shiraz; Everett, Jeff; Neu, Dean (2007). "Accounting and the move to privatize water services in Africa". Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal. 20 (5). Emerald Group Publishing Limited: 637–670. doi:10.1108/09513570710778992., p. 648-651
  43. ^ a b Vitens Evides International. "Management Contract 2006–2011 for urban water supply in Ghana A Partnership – in and for – development" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 16 June 2013. Retrieved 14 August 2012.
  44. ^ Doe, Henry Wonder (2007). "Assessing the Challenges of Water Supply in. Urban Ghana: The case of North Teshie. (EESI Master Thesis)" (PDF). Stockholm: Department of Land and Water Resources Engineering, Royal Institute of Technology (KTH). Retrieved 27 March 2008. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)[permanent dead link], p. 35-36
  45. ^ Benson, Ivy (12 March 2008). "Government maintains Aqua Vitens deal…to manage water supply in the country". The Ghanaian Chronicle. Retrieved 27 March 2008.[permanent dead link].
  46. ^ a b c World Bank. "Project Appraisal Document: Sustainable Water Supply and Sanitation Project, 28 May 2010" (PDF). Retrieved 19 August 2012.
  47. ^ a b c AMCW/AfDB/EUWI/WSP/UNDP: Getting Africa on Track to meet the MDGs on Water and Sanitation Archived 27 February 2008 at the Wayback Machine – A Status Overview of Sixteen African Countries, 2006, p. 27
  48. ^ Water-Aid Ghana (2005). "Assessment of national sanitation policies: Ghana case. Final report" (PDF). Accra. Retrieved 26 March 2008., p. 28-29
  49. ^ Doe, Henry Wonder (2007). "Assessing the Challenges of Water Supply in. Urban Ghana: The case of North Teshie. (EESI Master Thesis)" (PDF). Stockholm: Department of Land and Water Resources Engineering, Royal Institute of Technology (KTH). Retrieved 27 March 2008. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)[permanent dead link], p. 33
  50. ^ Appiah, Innocent (28 February 2008). "Govt tackles water issue". Ghanaian Times.
  51. ^ a b Water-Aid Ghana (2005). "Assessment of national sanitation policies: Ghana case. Final report" (PDF). Accra. Retrieved 26 March 2008., p. 19
  52. ^ RUAF Ghana Sanitation Report
  53. ^ Community Water and Sanitation Agency (CWSA) (August 2004). "Strategic Investment Plan 2005 – 2015" (PDF). Retrieved 26 March 2008.[dead link], p. 15
  54. ^ Community Water and Sanitation Agency (CWSA) (August 2004). "Strategic Investment Plan 2005 – 2015" (PDF). Retrieved 26 March 2008.[dead link], p. 9-11
  55. ^ Nyarko, Kwabena Biritwum (2004). "Institutional challenges for small towns' water supply delivery in Ghana". In Chaoka, T. R.; et al. (eds.). Water Resources of Arid and Semi Arid Regions, International Conference. London: Taylor and Francis Group. pp. 217–226. ISBN 0-415-35913-9., p. 217-218.
  56. ^ a b Komives, K.; Akanbang, B.; Thorsten, R.; Tuffuor, B.; Wakeman, Wasser.; Larbi, E.; Bakalian, A; Whittington, D. (2008). "Post-construction Support and the Sustainability of Rural Water Projects in Ghana". Paper Presented at the 33rd WEDC International Conference – Access to Sanitation and Safe Water: Global Partnerships and Local Actions. Accra., p. 2
  57. ^ Water-Aid Ghana (2005). "Assessment of national sanitation policies: Ghana case. Final report" (PDF). Accra. Retrieved 26 March 2008., p. 31
  58. ^ a b KfW Entwicklungsbank. "Ghana: Rural Water Supply I -II Ex post evaluation, 2005" (PDF). Retrieved 19 August 2012.
  59. ^ CONIWAS
  60. ^ "Research | Innovations for Poverty Action". www.poverty-action.org. 6 August 2015. Retrieved 8 May 2016.
  61. ^ "What We Do | Innovations for Poverty Action". www.poverty-action.org. 11 February 2015. Retrieved 8 May 2016.
  62. ^ "Clean Water in Northern Ghana | Innovations for Poverty Action". www.poverty-action.org. 22 April 2015. Retrieved 8 May 2016.
  63. ^ "Pure Home Water, Tamale, Ghana. 2013" (PDF).
  64. ^ "Pure Home Water | Innovations for Poverty Action". www.poverty-action.org. 10 April 2015. Retrieved 8 May 2016.
  65. ^ "Pure Home Water". Pure Home Water. Retrieved 8 May 2016.
  66. ^ "Saha Global". sahaglobal.org. Retrieved 7 May 2016.
  67. ^ "About Us – Learn About Our Clean Water Solutions | Water.org". Water.org. Retrieved 8 May 2016.
  68. ^ "Ghana – Water Crisis | Water.org". Water.org. Retrieved 8 May 2016.
  69. ^ "Opportunity in Ghana". Water.org. Retrieved 8 May 2016.
  70. ^ Water Sector Restructuring Secretariat. "Water for Ghana website". Archived from the original on 3 April 2007. Retrieved 27 March 2008. .
  71. ^ "Illegal water connections hampering GWCL". Kessben FM radio station. 11 March 2008. Archived from the original on 25 June 2009. Retrieved 27 March 2008. .
  72. ^ Abayie, Henrietta (10 March 2008). "Few People Pay For Water". Daily Guide Newspaper. Archived from the original on 1 November 2007. Retrieved 27 March 2008. .
  73. ^ a b WaterAid. "National Water Sector Assessment, Ghana" (PDF). Retrieved 26 March 2008.[permanent dead link], p. 4
  74. ^ AVRL:The Dodowa Intervention
  75. ^ a b Doe, Henry Wonder (2007). "Assessing the Challenges of Water Supply in. Urban Ghana: The case of North Teshie. (EESI Master Thesis)" (PDF). Stockholm: Department of Land and Water Resources Engineering, Royal Institute of Technology (KTH). Retrieved 27 March 2008. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)[permanent dead link], p. 32
  76. ^ a b 1 Ghanaian Cedi = 0.0001132 US Dollar (31 December 2006); Source: http://www.oanda.com/
  77. ^ Nyarko, K. B.; Oduro-Kwarteng, S.; Adama, I. (2006). "Cost recovery of community-managed piped water systems in the Ashanti region, Ghana". Water and Environment Journal. 21 (2). Chartered Institution of Water and Environmental Management (CIWEM): 92–99. doi:10.1111/j.1747-6593.2006.00051.x. ISSN 1747-6585. S2CID 154378574.
  78. ^ Komives, K.; Akanbang, B.; Thorsten, R.; Tuffuor, B.; Wakeman, Wasser.; Larbi, E.; Bakalian, A; Whittington, D. (2008). "Post-construction Support and the Sustainability of Rural Water Projects in Ghana". Paper Presented at the 33rd WEDC International Conference – Access to Sanitation and Safe Water: Global Partnerships and Local Actions. Accra., p. 4
  79. ^ WaterAid. "National Water Sector Assessment, Ghana" (PDF). Retrieved 26 March 2008.[permanent dead link], p. 3
  80. ^ Water for Ghana. It is US$9 per capita in Nicaragua, more than US$4 per capita in Rwanda, US$3.7 per capita in Bolivia and less than US$1 per capita in Ethiopia
  81. ^ Global Water Intelligence (November 2012). "Ghana rules out further desalination". {{cite web}}: Missing or empty |url= (help)
  82. ^ "Asutsuare Water Treatment Plant – Summary of Investment Information". IFC. Retrieved 4 November 2014.
  83. ^ African Development Fund (October 2005). "Accra Sewerage Improvement Project (ASIP). Appraisal Report" (PDF). Retrieved 28 March 2008. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)[dead link]
  84. ^ Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA). "District Capacity Building Project (DISCAP)". Retrieved 28 March 2008.[dead link]
  85. ^ Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA). "Northern Region Water Sanitation Project (NORWASP)". Retrieved 28 March 2008.
  86. ^ Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA). "Northern Region Small Towns (NORST)". Archived from the original on 1 January 2013. Retrieved 28 March 2008.
  87. ^ KfW Entwicklungsbank. "Ghana: Programme – Decentralisation". Retrieved 19 August 2012.
  88. ^ a b World Bank. "A Demand-Driven Approach in Service-Delivery: The Community Water and Sanitation Program in Ghana". Retrieved 28 March 2008.
  89. ^ World Bank. "Small Towns Water Supply and Sanitation Project". Retrieved 28 March 2008.
  90. ^ World Bank. "Ghana: World Bank Turns US$103 Million Ghana Urban Water Credit To Grant". Retrieved 28 March 2008.
  91. ^ World Bank. "Urban Water Project". Retrieved 28 March 2008.

External links

Policy setting

Economic regulation

Service provision